Test the SQL Server database collation with PowerShell and dbatools

If your server collation is different to your database collation then you may find that you get an error similar to this

Cannot resolve the collation conflict between “SQL_Latin1_General_CP1_CI_AS” and “Latin1_General_CI_AS” in the equal to operation.

when your queries use the tempdb

It would be useful to be able to quickly test if that may be the case and with the dbatools module you can. There is a Test-DbaDatabaseCollation command which will do just that. This page will show you how to install dbatools if you have not already got it

As always you should start with Get-Help when looking at a PowerShell command

Get-Help TestDbaDatabaseCollation -ShowWindow


01 - Get Help.PNG

There are only 3 parameters Sqlserver, Credential and detailed

Lets start with SQLServer

Test-DbaDatabaseCollation -SqlServer SQLvNextN2

this gives a quick and simple output showing the server name, database name and an IsEqual property

02 - test server

So in this example we can see that the WideWorldImporters database does not have the same collation as the server. If we only wanted to see information about databases with a collation that does not match the server then we could use

(Test-DbaDatabaseCollation -SqlServer SQLvNextN2).Where{$_.IsEqual -eq $false}

03 - equals false

That doesn’t give us any further information though. There is the detailed parameter as well. Lets see what that does

 Test-DbaDatabaseCollation -SqlServer SQLvNextN2 -Detailed

04 - detailed.PNG

This time we get the server name, server collation, database name , database collation and the IsEqual property. This is a collection of objects so we are not bound be just seeing them on the screen we can use them as I blogged about here

For example

 ## Output to a file
Test-DbaDatabaseCollation -SqlServer SQLvNextN2 -Detailed |Out-File C:\Temp\CollationCheck.txt
## Output to CSV
Test-DbaDatabaseCollation -SqlServer SQLvNextN2 -Detailed |Export-Csv  C:\temp\CollationCheck.csv -NoTypeInformation
<## Output to JSON
Test-DbaDatabaseCollation -SqlServer SQLvNextN2 -Detailed | ConvertTo-Json | Out-file c:\temp\CollationCheck.json
## Look at the files
notepad C:\temp\CollationCheck.json
notepad C:\temp\CollationCheck.csv
notepad C:\temp\CollationCheck.txt

Of course, you will probably want to test more than one server at a time. Lets pass an array of servers and see what happens

$SQLServers = (Get-VM -ComputerName beardnuc | Where-Object {$_.Name -like '*SQL*' -and $_.Name -ne 'SQL2008Ser2008' -and $_.State -eq 'Running'}).Name
# Test Db collation
Test-DbaDatabaseCollation -SqlServer $SQLServers -Detailed 
05 - servers.PNG

In this example, I am querying my Hyper-V server for all VMs with SQL in the name,except for my broken SQL2008 box ,that are running. I love PowerShell’s Out-GridView command for many reasons. The ability to sort by columns quickly and simply is one of them. Lets add that to the code and sort by the IsEquals column

$SQLServers = (Get-VM -ComputerName beardnuc | Where-Object {$_.Name -like '*SQL*' -and $_.Name -ne 'SQL2008Ser2008' -and $_.State -eq 'Running'}).Name
# Test Db collation
Test-DbaDatabaseCollation -SqlServer $SQLServers -Detailed | Out-GridView
06 - servers ogv.PNG

Excellent, that works a treat. How about Linux? Does this work if SQL is running on Linux? We will have to use the credential parameter as we need SQL Authentication. this time I have used the Format-Table command to format the output.

$cred = Get-Credential
Test-DbaDatabaseCollation -SqlServer LinuxvNextCTP14 -Credential $cred -Detailed | Format-Table -AutoSize
07 - Linux.PNG

Lets add some Pester tests. If we want to test a list of servers and see if any of their databases have an incorrect collation we can simply test if the IsEquals flag contains a false.

We can do this using TestCases. Test cases allow Pester to loop through a collection of ‘things’ The testcases parameter takes an array of hashtables. This all sounds very complicated to those unclear about PowerShell but here some code to do it.

$SQLServers = (Get-VM -ComputerName beardnuc | Where-Object {$_.Name -like '*SQL*' -and $_.Name -ne 'SQL2008Ser2008' -and $_.State -eq 'Running'}).Name
$testCases= @()
$SQLServers.ForEach{$testCases += @{Name = $_}}

The first line gathers the list of SQL Servers from the Hyper-V as before. You can get this from a text file, csv, Active Directory, CMS, registered servers list. The second line initiates the TestCases array and the third line iterates through the list of servers and adds a hashtable to the TestCases array

To make use of the test cases we have to use the -TestCases parameter in our It block of our Pester Test and add a param() so that the test knows where to get the values from. To add the value from the test cases into the title of the test we need to reference it inside <>

If you want to learn more about Pester. I highly recommend The Pester Book by Don Jones and Adam Bertram

Here is the code

Describe "Testing Database Collation" {
    $SQLServers = (Get-VM -ComputerName beardnuc | Where-Object {$_.Name -like '*SQL*' -and $_.Name -ne 'SQL2008Ser2008' -and $_.State -eq 'Running'}).Name
    $testCases= @()
    $SQLServers.ForEach{$testCases += @{Name = $_}}
    It "<Name> databases have the right collation" -TestCases $testCases {
        $Collation = Test-DbaDatabaseCollation -SqlServer $Name
        $Collation.IsEqual -contains $false | Should Be $false

If we save that as a PowerShell file, we can call it with Invoke-Pester

08 - Servers Pester.PNG

which shows which servers do not have databases with the correct collation. This may be all that is required but what about if you want to check each database on each server with Pester?

I could not see a way to do this with TestCases so I reverted to PowerShell. Pester is just PowerShell code after all.

Describe "Testing Database Collation" {
    $SQLServers = (Get-VM -ComputerName beardnuc | Where-Object {$_.Name -like '*SQL*' -and $_.Name -ne 'SQL2008Ser2008' -and $_.State -eq 'Running'}).Name
    foreach($Server in $SQLServers)
        $CollationTests = Test-DbaDatabaseCollation -SqlServer $Server
        foreach($CollationTest in $CollationTests)
            It "$($Collationtest.Server) database $($CollationTest.Database) should have the correct collation" {
                $CollationTest.IsEqual | Should Be $true

In this example, we again gather the names of our SQL servers and then iterate through them. Then set the results of the Test-DBADatabaseCollation to a variable and iterate through each of the results and test the IsEquals property. We can save that as a file and call it with Invoke-Pester and this time it looks like

09 - Individual databases.PNG

Excellent we can quickly and easily see which database on which server doesnot have a matching collation. We cant see in the results of the Pester test what collation it should be though. Lets do that as well.

This time we need to use the Detailed parameter and test that the ServerCollation matches the DatabaseCollation. This will enable Pester to display that information to us. Here is the code

Describe "Testing Database Collation" {
    $SQLServers = (Get-VM -ComputerName beardnuc | Where-Object {$_.Name -like '*SQL*' -and $_.Name -ne 'SQL2008Ser2008' -and $_.State -eq 'Running'}).Name
    foreach($Server in $SQLServers)
        $CollationTests = Test-DbaDatabaseCollation -SqlServer $Server -Detailed
        foreach($CollationTest in $CollationTests)
            It "$($Collationtest.Server) database $($CollationTest.Database) should have the correct collation of $($CollationTest.ServerCollation)" {
                $CollationTest.DatabaseCollation | Should Be $CollationTest.ServerCollation
and if we save that as a file and call it with invoke-Pester (you can just run the code using PowerShell as well) it looks like this
10 - full test.PNG

Now Pester shows us what collation it is expecting and what the collation of the database is as well when it fails the test. (I love the little arrow showing where the difference is!)

Hopefully this post has shown you how you can use Test-DbaDatabaseCollation from the dbatools module to test your servers and combine that with Pester. If you have any questions about the dbatools module go and ask in the dbatools channel in the SQL Community Slack channel


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s